← All SCORM guides

· SCORM Packager team · SCORM basics

What is SCORM? SCORM 1.2 vs SCORM 2004 explained

Short answer: SCORM is a standard that defines how an e-learning course is zipped (with an imsmanifest.xml at the root) and how it talks to the LMS at runtime through a JavaScript API. SCORM 1.2 is older and supported almost everywhere. SCORM 2004 separates completion from pass/fail, allows far more resume data and adds sequencing. Publish SCORM 1.2 unless you need one of those.

What is SCORM?

SCORM (Sharable Content Object Reference Model) is a set of specifications published by ADL, the US Advanced Distributed Learning initiative. It answers two questions every LMS has about a course: how do I import it, and how does it tell me what the learner did? Storyline, Rise, Captivate, iSpring and most other authoring tools can publish SCORM, and almost every LMS can import it. That is why a SCORM zip is still the default way to move a course between systems.

SCORM does not describe what a course looks like. A SCORM course is a small website (HTML, JavaScript, CSS, images, audio and video) plus a manifest that describes it, and a contract for how that website reports progress.

What is inside a SCORM package

  • imsmanifest.xml at the root of the zip. It names the course, lists its resources and points the LMS to the launch file. If this file is missing or sits inside a subfolder, the LMS rejects the upload.
  • The launch file and course content: an HTML page plus the scripts, styles and media it loads.
  • XML schema files (.xsd and .dtd) that the manifest refers to.
  • Often a "SCORM driver" or wrapper script from the authoring tool that finds the LMS API and translates the course's events into SCORM calls.

When the LMS launches the course, it opens the launch file in a frame or window and exposes a JavaScript object, called API in SCORM 1.2 and API_1484_11 in SCORM 2004. The course finds that object and calls it to start the session, read and write data such as status, score and bookmark, and end the session. Want to look inside one? See how to open a SCORM file without an LMS.

SCORM 1.2 vs SCORM 2004 at a glance

Practical differences between SCORM 1.2 and SCORM 2004 (3rd/4th edition)
SCORM 1.2SCORM 2004
Released20012004, with editions up to the 4th (2009)
API objectAPI (LMSInitialize, LMSGetValue, LMSSetValue, LMSCommit, LMSFinish)API_1484_11 (Initialize, GetValue, SetValue, Commit, Terminate)
StatusOne field, cmi.core.lesson_status: passed, completed, failed, incomplete, browsed or not attemptedTwo fields: cmi.completion_status (completed/incomplete) and cmi.success_status (passed/failed)
Scorecmi.core.score.raw, min and maxAdds cmi.score.scaled (-1 to 1)
Resume datacmi.suspend_data up to 4,096 characterscmi.suspend_data up to 64,000 characters
SequencingNone. The LMS launches each SCO; navigation is up to the courseOptional sequencing and navigation rules between SCOs
LMS supportNearly universalWidely supported, but some LMSs implement it only partially

Completion and pass/fail

In SCORM 1.2 a course can report "completed" or "passed", but not both, because there is only one status field. A learner who finishes every slide and then fails the quiz ends up as "failed" and loses the record that they completed the content. SCORM 2004 stores completion and success separately, which is what most compliance reporting actually wants.

Resume data

Authoring tools save the learner's position and interaction state in suspend_data. Long Storyline courses with many slides and variables can exceed the 4,096-character limit in SCORM 1.2. When that happens, resume silently breaks: learners reopen the course and start over. SCORM 2004 (3rd and 4th edition) raises the limit to 64,000 characters, and that is the most common practical reason to choose it.

Sequencing

SCORM 2004 lets a package with several SCOs define rules such as "unlock module 2 after module 1 is passed". Most single-SCO courses exported from Storyline or Rise do not use sequencing at all, so it rarely decides the version.

Which version should you publish?

  • Publish SCORM 1.2 when you do not know the target LMS, when it is Moodle (whose documentation states SCORM 2004 is not supported), or when the course is short. It is the safest choice.
  • Publish SCORM 2004 (3rd or 4th edition) when you need completion and pass/fail reported separately, or when a long course needs resume to work reliably.
  • Use xAPI or cmi5 when you need to track learning outside an LMS, such as in an app, a simulation or offline, and you have a learning record store.

What about xAPI and cmi5?

xAPI (Tin Can) sends statements such as "learner answered question 3" to a learning record store instead of calling an LMS API in the browser. That makes it flexible, but an LMS needs an LRS to make sense of the data. cmi5 is a profile of xAPI that restores LMS-style launch and completion rules. If your LMS supports cmi5 and you need xAPI data, it is the cleaner choice. Otherwise SCORM remains the format every LMS can import.

Frequently asked questions

Is SCORM 2004 better than SCORM 1.2?

It is more capable, not automatically better. SCORM 2004 separates completion from pass/fail and stores far more resume data, but SCORM 1.2 is supported more consistently across LMSs. Choose 2004 when you need those features and your LMS supports it well.

Can I convert a SCORM 1.2 course to SCORM 2004?

Republish from the authoring tool with the other version selected. Converting by hand means rewriting the manifest and every tracking call the course makes, because the two versions use different API objects and data fields, which is error-prone.

How do I tell which SCORM version a package uses?

Open imsmanifest.xml. A SCORM 1.2 manifest declares schemaversion 1.2 and uses adlcp:scormtype. A SCORM 2004 manifest declares a schemaversion such as "2004 3rd Edition" or "2004 4th Edition" and uses adlcp:scormType.

Does the SCORM version affect translation?

No. The course text lives in the HTML and data files, not in the SCORM tracking layer. A translated package keeps the original manifest and SCORM driver.

Sources

Product page: SCORM translation tool

Translate a SCORM 1.2 or 2004 course without rebuilding

Upload the published zip, translate text and media, review every string and download a package in the same SCORM version.

Free to try and preview · Download on any paid plan · No credit card required